Skip to main content
Explore giveaways & upcoming drops →
Drop BeaconDrop Beacon
Spyderco Para Military 2 in S110V, Spyderco Para Military 2 Lightweight Salt in MagnaCut and Spyderco Manix 2 in MagnaMax

S110V vs MagnaCut (and MagnaMax): Which Steel to Buy

knives
steel
knife steel
comparison
s110v
magnacut
magnamax
On this page▼

Drop Beacon may earn a commission when you buy through affiliate links on this page — at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

Short answer: Buy MagnaCut unless edge life matters more to you than anything else. S110V holds an edge longer, but MagnaCut is far tougher, at least as rust resistant, cheaper on the same knife and sold by many more makers. If you want S110V's edge life, MagnaMax matches it with more toughness, though it costs more and most MagnaMax knives are automatics.

All three are stainless powder steels. S110V is the oldest, and in Drop Beacon's catalogue it is almost entirely a Spyderco steel.

Two terms used below. HRC is the Rockwell C hardness scale, where a higher number means a harder blade (how hardness affects a knife). CATRA is a machine test that measures how much abrasive card a blade cuts before it goes dull.

S110V vs MagnaCut vs MagnaMax at a glance

S110VMagnaCutMagnaMax
Designed byCrucible; patent filed 2006Larrin Thomas; on sale 2021Larrin Thomas; introduced 2026
Chromium15.25%10.7%Not stated in text sources
Carbide volumeAbout 27%About 8%About 16%
HardnessDatasheet: 58 to 61 HRC in useDatasheet aim of 60 to 63 HRCTested at 62 HRC
Edge retentionHigh; level with CPM-10VLower; level with S35VN and CPM-4VHigh; level with S110V
ToughnessLowest of the threeHighest; 38 ft-lbs at 62.5 HRCBetween the two; level with S35VN
Rust (1% saltwater test)A few small spotsNo rustNo rust
Listings tracked57About 7,400185
In stock35About 2,40082
Median listed price$249About $330$349
First seen in the last 90 days0About 90062

Listing figures are from Drop Beacon's catalogue on 17 November 2026. The saltwater results come from two separate test runs by Knife Steel Nerds.

What S110V, MagnaCut and MagnaMax are

CPM S110V came from Crucible. Knife Steel Nerds records that its patent was filed in 2006, its first datasheet appeared in 2008 and the composition was revised in 2010. The current datasheet lists 2.8% carbon, 15.25% chromium, 9% vanadium, 3% niobium, 2.25% molybdenum and 2.5% cobalt. Carbides are the hard particles in a steel that resist wear, and S110V has a lot of them: about 27% by volume in Knife Steel Nerds' micrograph. It was designed to improve on S90V's rust resistance.

MagnaCut is Dr. Larrin Thomas's stainless steel for knives, sold since April 2021. Its datasheet lists 1.15% carbon, 10.7% chromium, 4% vanadium, 2% molybdenum, 2% niobium and 0.2% nitrogen. It has no chromium carbides, only small vanadium and niobium ones, which is why a steel with less chromium than S110V resists rust at least as well.

MagnaMax is Thomas's follow-up, with about 16% carbide, roughly double MagnaCut. He wrote in January 2026 that the first commercial batch had reached a few knife companies. It is covered in full in MagnaMax vs MagnaCut.

MagnaMax Cuts Longer. Why Keep MagnaCut? · Watch on YouTube

Edge retention: S110V beats MagnaCut and ties MagnaMax

Edge retention is how long a blade keeps cutting before it needs sharpening.

  • S110V. In Knife Steel Nerds' CATRA testing it landed level with CPM-10V. Thomas notes it did worse than S90V, which surprised him because the two steels are similar.
  • MagnaCut. Thomas's CATRA testing put it level with S35VN, CPM-4V and CPM-CruWear. Its datasheet lists 135% of the reference steel 440C, against 195% for S90V.
  • A second test. In knifemaker Phil Wilson's rope cutting, reported by Knife Steel Nerds, MagnaCut at 62.5 HRC made 45 cuts and S90V or S110V made 60. That is a third more for S110V.
  • MagnaMax. Niagara, citing Thomas's testing, puts it about 40% ahead of MagnaCut at 62 HRC, and Thomas places it in the same range as S110V and CPM-10V.

So S110V and MagnaMax both cut roughly a third to 40% longer than MagnaCut in the tests available. None of these tests ran all three steels together with the numbers stated in text.

Toughness: MagnaCut first, MagnaMax second, S110V last

Toughness is a steel's resistance to chipping and breaking. This is where S110V gives ground.

MagnaCut's datasheet lists 38 ft-lbs at 62.5 HRC. The same table lists S90V at 17 ft-lbs at 61 HRC. S110V is not in that table, but Knife Steel Nerds ranks S110V below S90V for toughness, which suggests it has less than half of MagnaCut's toughness.

MagnaMax sits between them. Thomas says it took a small cut in toughness from MagnaCut and tested just above S35VN, which the MagnaCut datasheet lists at 25 ft-lbs at 61 HRC. Niagara's interview with Thomas puts MagnaMax at roughly double the toughness of S90V, 20CV and M390.

Rust resistance: all three are stainless

S110V has more chromium than MagnaCut (Niagara's data sheet does not give MagnaMax's composition), but the saltwater tests favour the two newer steels.

  • In Thomas's 1% saltwater test for the MagnaMax article, MagnaMax showed no rust spots, S110V and M390 showed a few small spots, and S90V rusted significantly.
  • In his earlier MagnaCut test, MagnaCut showed no visible corrosion after 72 hours in 1% saltwater.
  • Knife Steel Nerds describes S110V as a significant upgrade over S90V for rust resistance and similar to M390.

All three are stainless steels. MagnaCut and MagnaMax have the cleaner test results.

Sharpening S110V and MagnaCut

S110V's datasheet says it is harder to machine and grind than 440C or D2 and about the same as S90V or slightly harder. Knife Steel Nerds notes that some users report trouble removing the burr when sharpening S110V. One knifemaker quoted by Knife Steel Nerds found MagnaCut easier to grind and sharpen than CPM-4V. No sharpening test of MagnaMax has been published in the sources opened for this article.

All three contain vanadium carbides, which are harder than common aluminium oxide stones. Diamond or CBN stones cut them more easily, and that matters most for S110V, which has the most carbide.

MagnaMax vs S110V: same edge life, more toughness

This is the closest comparison of the three, because both steels aim at very long edge life in a stainless blade. Thomas summarises MagnaMax as having "similar edge retention to S110V but substantially higher toughness". It also did better in his saltwater test, with no rust spots against a few small ones.

On the published tests MagnaMax is the stronger steel. S110V's advantages are price and format:

  • S110V is cheaper. Its in-stock listings start at $146.25 and the median listed price is $249. MagnaMax in-stock listings priced in US dollars start at $285 and the median is $349.
  • S110V comes in manual Spyderco folders in several sizes. 161 of the 185 MagnaMax listings are Pro-Tech and Guardian Tactical knives, which are automatics.
  • MagnaMax is the one still growing: 62 new listings in 90 days against none for S110V.

Price and availability: what Drop Beacon's catalogue shows

These figures are from Drop Beacon's catalogue on 17 November 2026. A listing is one knife at one store, so the same knife at three stores counts three times.

  • S110V: 57 listings from 11 sellers. 55 are Spyderco knives. The other two are Shirogorov knives. 35 are in stock. The median listed price is $249, and the middle half of listings fall between $200 and $270. No S110V listing was first seen in the last 90 days.
  • MagnaCut: about 7,400 listings from 148 makers and stores. About 2,400 are in stock. The median listed price is about $330, with the middle half between $240 and $500, and about 600 in-stock listings are under $200. About 900 listings were first seen in the last 90 days.
  • MagnaMax: 185 listings from 7 makers. 82 are in stock, the median listed price is $349, and 62 listings were first seen in the last 90 days.

The 90-day counts leave out Blade HQ, whose listings all carry the same load date in the catalogue.

Spyderco gives its S110V knives dark blue handles, so they are easy to spot. The catalogue lists the Manix 2, Military, Military 2, Para 3, Para Military 2, Native 5, Native Chief and UK Penknife in S110V.

Browse S110V knives, browse MagnaCut knives or browse MagnaMax knives.

Same Spyderco in S110V and MagnaCut: the price gap

Spyderco sells some models in both steels, which shows what the steel alone costs. Prices are Blade HQ's on 17 November 2026, and all five listings were in stock.

Spyderco modelStandard steelMagnaCutS110V
Paramilitary 2, G-10 handle$209.25 (S45VN)$213.00 (Salt version)$258.75
Manix 2 Lightweightnot compared$158.25 (Salt version)$188.25

S110V costs $45.75 more than MagnaCut on the Paramilitary 2 and $30.00 more on the Manix 2 Lightweight, about 20% in both cases.

Who should buy S110V, MagnaCut or MagnaMax

Buy MagnaCut if you want one knife for mixed use, including harder work, and you want the widest choice of knives and prices. That describes most buyers.

Buy S110V if you want long edge life in a manual Spyderco folder for under $260, you mostly slice, and you sharpen with diamond stones.

Buy MagnaMax if you want S110V's edge life with more toughness, you are willing to pay around $310 to $375, and an automatic suits you or one of the few manual MagnaMax folders does.

Is S110V better than MagnaCut?

For edge retention, yes: in a knifemaker's rope-cutting test reported by Knife Steel Nerds, S110V made about a third more cuts. For toughness MagnaCut is well ahead, with a datasheet figure more than double that of S90V, which Knife Steel Nerds ranks above S110V. MagnaCut showed no rust in a 1% saltwater test, while S110V showed a few small spots in a later test of the same kind. MagnaCut also costs $30 to $46 less on the same Spyderco model. For most buyers MagnaCut is the better steel.

Is MagnaMax better than S110V?

On published tests, yes. Larrin Thomas reports that MagnaMax has edge retention similar to S110V with substantially higher toughness, and it showed no rust spots in a saltwater test where S110V showed a few. S110V is cheaper and is sold in more manual folders. In Drop Beacon's catalogue on 17 November 2026 the median listed price was $249 for S110V and $349 for MagnaMax.

Is S110V still worth buying in 2026?

Yes, for a specific buyer. S110V remains one of the longest-cutting stainless steels, and Spyderco's S110V models start at $146.25 in stock in Drop Beacon's catalogue. The catalogue has had no new S110V listing in 90 days while MagnaCut and MagnaMax keep adding knives, which suggests few new S110V models are arriving. A buyer who wants a tougher blade should choose MagnaCut or MagnaMax.

Six knives in S110V, MagnaCut and MagnaMax, with live prices

Live prices from the stores Drop Beacon tracks. Two knives in each steel.

Sources

Last updated: 17 November 2026.

Discussion

Sign in to leave a comment.