Skip to main content
Explore giveaways & upcoming drops →
Drop BeaconDrop Beacon
Spyderco Tenacious in M4 beside a Spyderco Para Military 2 Lightweight Salt in MagnaCut

M4 vs MagnaCut: Which Knife Steel to Buy, and for Whom

knives
steel
knife steel
comparison
m4
magnacut
On this page▼

Drop Beacon may earn a commission when you buy through affiliate links on this page — at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

Short answer: Buy MagnaCut unless you want a particular knife that only comes in M4. MagnaCut is stainless, it tested tougher than CPM-M4, and it is in about 35 times as many listings. M4's one advantage on the published data is a slightly longer-lasting edge at the same hardness, and it needs to be kept dry and oiled to avoid rust.

M4 here means CPM-M4, the powder version of a high speed tool steel. It is the M4 used in knives from Benchmade, Spyderco, Kershaw and others.

Two terms used below. HRC is the Rockwell C hardness scale, where a higher number means a harder blade (how hardness affects a knife). CATRA is a machine test that measures how much abrasive card a blade cuts before it goes dull.

M4 vs MagnaCut at a glance

CPM-M4MagnaCut
TypeHigh speed tool steel, not stainlessStainless
Chromium4.3%10.7%
OriginCrucible's powder version of M4Designed by Larrin Thomas, on sale 2021
HardnessDatasheet tempers reach 66 HRC; knives run 60 to 64 or moreDatasheet aim of 60 to 63 HRC
Edge retentionA little ahead at equal hardnessLevel with S35VN and CPM-4V
Toughness (datasheets)28 ft-lbs at 63 HRC38 ft-lbs at 62.5 HRC
RustNot stainless; needs careNo rust after 72 hours of 1% salt spray
Listings tracked212 from 22 sellersAbout 7,400 from 148 makers and stores
In stock111About 2,400
Median listed price$294About $330
First seen in the last 90 days3About 900

Listing figures are from Drop Beacon's catalogue on 17 November 2026. The two toughness figures come from separate datasheets.

What CPM-M4 and MagnaCut are

CPM-M4 is a high speed steel, the family used for drills and industrial cutters. Its datasheet describes it as a steel designed for high wear resistance in tools, with better wear resistance than the M2 and M3 grades. The listed composition is 1.3% carbon, 4.3% chromium, 5.6% tungsten, 4.5% molybdenum and 4% vanadium. It is made from powder, which keeps its carbides small. Carbides are the hard particles in a steel that resist wear. Spyderco's CPM-M4 Mule Team blade is dated October 2008 on its product page, so M4 has been in production knives for well over a decade.

MagnaCut is a stainless powder steel designed for knives by Dr. Larrin Thomas, the metallurgist who writes Knife Steel Nerds. Its datasheet lists 1.15% carbon, 10.7% chromium, 4% vanadium, 2% molybdenum, 2% niobium and 0.2% nitrogen. It was designed to contain no chromium carbides, which leaves its chromium free to resist rust. Niagara Specialty Metals began selling it in April 2021. Knife Steel Nerds describes its properties as similar to balanced tool steels such as CPM-4V and CPM-CruWear, with stainless rust resistance added.

Edge retention: M4 leads MagnaCut by a small margin

Edge retention is how long a blade keeps cutting before it needs sharpening. No source opened for this article states CATRA numbers for both steels in text, so the comparison rests on two statements from Knife Steel Nerds:

  • MagnaCut roughly matched S35VN, CPM-4V and CPM-CruWear in CATRA testing.
  • CPM-M4 has a bit better edge retention than CPM-4V, at the cost of some toughness.

Together they put M4 slightly ahead of MagnaCut at similar hardness. The gap is small. In Thomas's MagnaMax testing, CPM-M4 sits in the group of steels below MagnaMax, alongside M390 and S30V.

Hardness can matter more than the steel name. Knife Steel Nerds' analysis of its CATRA results found that each point of Rockwell hardness adds to the amount of card cut. M4's datasheet lists tempers that give 63 to 65 HRC, and Thomas notes that M4 knives range from 60 to 64 HRC or more. MagnaCut's datasheet aims for 60 to 63 HRC. An M4 blade run two points harder than a MagnaCut blade will widen the gap. An M4 blade run softer can close it.

Toughness: MagnaCut tested tougher than M4

Toughness is a steel's resistance to chipping and breaking. Knife Steel Nerds states that MagnaCut's toughness tested better than CPM-M4's.

The datasheets agree on the direction. MagnaCut's lists 38 ft-lbs at 62.5 HRC. CPM-M4's lists 28 ft-lbs at 63 HRC and 20 ft-lbs at 65 HRC. The two sheets were not produced in one test programme, so the numbers show direction, not an exact ratio.

M4 is still a tough steel by the standard of its class. Knife Steel Nerds lists CPM-M4, CPM-4V and CPM-CruWear as the balanced choices among the tool steels that are not stainless.

Rust: M4 is not stainless

CPM-M4 has 4.3% chromium. Knife Steel Nerds treats about 10% as the level at which a steel is probably stainless. Spyderco's own page for its M4 Mule Team blade says plainly that it is a non-stainless steel.

Makers often coat M4 blades. Benchmade describes the Bailout's CPM-M4 blade as Cerakote finished. In Drop Beacon's catalogue the Kershaw Launch 21 is listed with a black blade and the Zero Tolerance 0203 with a black PVD coating. A coating covers the sides of the blade, not the sharpened edge, so an M4 knife still needs to be dried after use and kept lightly oiled.

MagnaCut showed no visible corrosion after 72 hours of 1% saltwater spray in Knife Steel Nerds' test, where 20CV showed small spots.

Hardness and sharpening

No sharpening test comparing the two has been published in the sources opened for this article. Spyderco calls CPM-M4 relatively easy to sharpen on its Mule Team page. One knifemaker quoted by Knife Steel Nerds found MagnaCut easier to grind and sharpen than CPM-4V. Both steels contain 4% vanadium, and vanadium carbides are harder than common aluminium oxide stones, so diamond or CBN stones suit both.

Price and availability: what Drop Beacon's catalogue shows

These figures are from Drop Beacon's catalogue on 17 November 2026. A listing is one knife at one store, so the same knife at three stores counts three times.

  • CPM-M4: 212 listings from 22 sellers. Benchmade accounts for 82, Toor Knives 28, Kershaw 26, Pena 23, Suprlativ 14, Demko 10, Spyderco 10, Zero Tolerance 10 and Hogue 8. 111 are in stock. The median listed price is $294, and the middle half of listings fall between $205 and $325. The lowest in-stock price is $99.75, for a Spyderco Tenacious in M4 at Chicago Knife Works, and Kershaw's M4 Launch automatics start at $121.50. The CPM-M4 page's headline price, $130.00, counts only listings that name the steel in their title. Automatic knives are restricted in some places, so check local law.
  • MagnaCut: about 7,400 listings from 148 makers and stores. About 2,400 are in stock. The median listed price is about $330, with the middle half between $240 and $500. About 600 in-stock listings are under $200 and 16 are under $100.
  • New listings. 3 CPM-M4 listings were first seen in the last 90 days, against about 900 for MagnaCut. The 90-day counts leave out Blade HQ, whose listings all carry the same load date in the catalogue.

Price does not separate the two. The median in-stock listing is about $275 for both. What separates them is choice: MagnaCut is offered in many knife types and by 148 makers and stores, while M4 is concentrated in a few lines, such as Benchmade's Bailout, Freek and Immunity models, Kershaw's Launch 16 and 21, and Toor's fixed blades.

Browse CPM-M4 knives or browse MagnaCut knives.

Same knife in M4 and MagnaCut: the Kershaw Bel Air XL

Kershaw sells the Bel Air XL in both steels. On 17 November 2026 Blade HQ listed the MagnaCut version with a black G-10 handle at $189.95. Three stores listed the CPM-M4 version with a flat dark earth aluminium handle at $143.37, $164.99 and $199.95. All four listings were in stock. On this knife the store matters more to the price than the steel does.

Who should buy M4, and who should buy MagnaCut

Buy MagnaCut if you want a knife that needs no rust care, you want the tougher blade, or you want a wide choice of knives. That describes most buyers.

Buy M4 if the knife you want only comes in M4, you prefer a coated tool steel blade, and you will dry and oil it. You get a slightly longer-lasting edge in return.

For other tool steels in this class, see M4 vs Cruwear vs Maxamet.

Is M4 better than MagnaCut?

Only for edge retention, and only slightly. Knife Steel Nerds puts CPM-M4 a bit ahead of CPM-4V for edge retention and puts MagnaCut level with CPM-4V. MagnaCut tested tougher than CPM-M4 and is stainless, which M4 is not. For most buyers MagnaCut is the better steel.

Does CPM-M4 rust?

Yes, if it is neglected. CPM-M4 contains 4.3% chromium, well under the roughly 10% that marks a probably stainless steel, and Spyderco describes it as non-stainless. Many M4 knives have coated blades, but the edge itself is bare steel. Dry the blade after use and keep a light coat of oil on it.

Which knives come in CPM-M4?

In Drop Beacon's catalogue on 17 November 2026, the CPM-M4 listings include Benchmade's Bailout, Freek, Mini Freek, Full Immunity and Partial Immunity, Kershaw's Launch 16, Launch 21 and Bel Air XL, the Zero Tolerance 0203, Spyderco's Tenacious in M4, Demko's AD20S, Pena's Cobra and Sicario, Hogue's Extrak fixed blades and many Toor Knives fixed blades.

Six knives in M4 and MagnaCut, with live prices

Live prices from the stores Drop Beacon tracks. Three CPM-M4 knives first, then three MagnaCut knives.

Sources

Last updated: 17 November 2026.

Discussion

Sign in to leave a comment.