Skip to main content
Explore giveaways & upcoming drops →
Drop BeaconDrop Beacon
Spyderco Manix 2 in MagnaMax beside a Spyderco Manix 2 in Cru-Wear

MagnaMax vs Cruwear: Which Knife Steel to Buy, and for Whom

knives
steel
knife steel
comparison
magnamax
cruwear
On this page▼

Drop Beacon may earn a commission when you buy through affiliate links on this page — at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

Short answer: Choose MagnaMax if you want the longer-lasting edge and a stainless blade. Choose Cru-Wear if you want the tougher blade, a lower price and far more manual folders to pick from. No direct test of the two with numbers stated in text was found for this article, so both halves of that verdict rest on how each steel compares with MagnaCut.

Cruwear, CruWear and Cru-Wear are the same steel. This article uses Cru-Wear, and it means the powder version, CPM Cru-Wear.

Two terms used below. HRC is the Rockwell C hardness scale, where a higher number means a harder blade (how hardness affects a knife). CATRA is a machine test that measures how much abrasive card a blade cuts before it goes dull.

MagnaMax vs Cruwear at a glance

MagnaMaxCru-Wear
TypeStainless powder steelPowder tool steel, not stainless
ChromiumNot stated in text sources7.5%
OriginDesigned by Larrin Thomas; introduced 2026Crucible's version of Vasco Wear; Cru-Wear dates to 1994
Carbide volumeAbout 16%About 10%
HardnessTested at 62 HRC; makers list 61 to 64.5 HRCDatasheet aim of 62 HRC; treatable to 60 to 65
Edge retentionAbout 40% more than MagnaCutAbout level with MagnaCut
ToughnessLevel with S35VNHigher; in the class of CPM-4V
RustNo rust spots in a 1% saltwater testSome stain resistance, not stainless
Listings tracked185 from 7 makers225 from 20 sellers
In stock8297
Median listed price$349$280
First seen in the last 90 days6217

Listing figures are from Drop Beacon's catalogue on 17 November 2026. They cover listings priced in US dollars, so Maserin's MagnaMax folder, priced in euros, is not counted.

What MagnaMax and Cru-Wear are

MagnaMax is a stainless powder steel designed by Dr. Larrin Thomas, the metallurgist who writes Knife Steel Nerds and who designed MagnaCut. He describes it as MagnaCut's recipe with more carbon, vanadium and niobium. Carbides are the hard particles in a steel that resist wear. MagnaMax has about 16% carbide by volume, roughly double MagnaCut, with no chromium carbides. Thomas wrote in January 2026 that the first commercial batch had reached a few knife companies. Niagara Specialty Metals sells it.

Cru-Wear is a tool steel with a long history. Knife Steel Nerds traces it to Vasco Wear, a steel from Vasco Metals, and records that Crucible introduced its own version as Cru-Wear in 1994. The powder version, CPM Cru-Wear, has the same composition as Carpenter's PD#1 and Zapp's Z-Wear. The datasheet lists 1.15% carbon, 7.5% chromium, 2.4% vanadium, 1.6% molybdenum and 1% tungsten, and describes it as an upgrade to A2 and D2 with better wear resistance and toughness. Knife Steel Nerds reported in January 2026 that Niagara has kept it in production under the name NSM Wear.

MagnaMax Cuts Longer. Why Keep MagnaCut? · Watch on YouTube

Edge retention: MagnaMax holds an edge longer than Cru-Wear

Edge retention is how long a blade keeps cutting before it needs sharpening. Both steels have been measured against MagnaCut, which gives a way to compare them.

  • Thomas's CATRA testing put MagnaCut level with S35VN, CPM-4V and CPM-CruWear. He also describes CPM-4V and CPM Cru-Wear as having roughly comparable properties.
  • Niagara, citing Thomas's testing, puts MagnaMax about 40% ahead of MagnaCut at 62 HRC. Thomas places it level with K390 and in the same range as CPM-10V and S110V.

If Cru-Wear is about level with MagnaCut and MagnaMax is about 40% ahead of MagnaCut, MagnaMax should hold an edge clearly longer than Cru-Wear at similar hardness. That is a comparison made through a third steel, not a direct test.

Hardness can shift the result. Cru-Wear's datasheet aims for 62 HRC and allows up to 65. One maker in Drop Beacon's catalogue, Jack Wolf Knives, lists 63 to 64 HRC on a Cru-Wear fixed blade. For MagnaMax, Maserin lists 61 to 63 HRC and McNees lists 63.5 to 64.5 HRC.

Toughness: Cru-Wear is likely the tougher steel

Toughness is a steel's resistance to chipping and breaking. Again there is no side-by-side test in text, so this section sets out what each source says.

  • Knife Steel Nerds lists CPM-CruWear, CPM-4V and CPM-M4 as the balanced choices among tool steels that are not stainless, and says the powder version of Cru-Wear showed very good toughness up to relatively high hardness.
  • Thomas says MagnaMax took a small cut in toughness from MagnaCut and tested just above S35VN. MagnaCut itself is the steel he compares with CPM-4V and CPM-CruWear.
  • In Knife Steel Nerds' toughness database, Z-Wear, which has the same composition as CPM Cru-Wear, scores 22.5 ft-lbs at 61.9 HRC. Thomas rates CPM-CruWear 8 out of 10 for toughness and MagnaCut 7, and MagnaMax sits below MagnaCut.

Those three points agree: Cru-Wear is likely the tougher steel. None of the three is a side-by-side test.

Cru-Wear's own datasheet lists 35 ft-lbs at 62 HRC, against 21 ft-lbs for D2 at 60 HRC. That figure does not come from the same test as the Knife Steel Nerds database, so the two sets of numbers should not be mixed.

Rust: MagnaMax is stainless, Cru-Wear is not

MagnaMax showed no rust spots in Thomas's 1% saltwater test. In the same test M390 and S110V showed a few small spots.

Cru-Wear has 7.5% chromium. Knife Steel Nerds treats about 10% as the level at which a steel is probably stainless. Of Cru-Wear and its relatives it says they would not be confused with stainless grades but should offer some stain resistance. Some makers coat it: Benchmade describes the Cru-Wear blade of its Anonimus as Cerakote finished. A Cru-Wear blade should be dried after use.

Hardness and sharpening

No sharpening test comparing the two has been published in the sources opened for this article. MagnaMax has more carbide, about 16% against about 10% for Cru-Wear, and its carbides are the hard vanadium and niobium type, so it should take longer to sharpen. Vanadium carbides are harder than common aluminium oxide stones, so diamond or CBN stones suit both steels and matter more for MagnaMax.

What Drop Beacon's catalogue shows for MagnaMax and Cru-Wear

These figures are from Drop Beacon's catalogue on 17 November 2026. A listing is one knife at one store, so the same knife at three stores counts three times.

  • Cru-Wear: 225 listings from 20 sellers. Spyderco accounts for 88, Benchmade 80, Zero Tolerance 27, Toor Knives 12, Kizer 6 and LynchNW 4. 97 are in stock. The median listed price is $280, and the middle half of listings fall between $229 and $325. The lowest in-stock price is $177.00, for Civil Ware's Striker fixed blade at Chicago Knife Works. The Cru-Wear page's headline price, $189.00, counts only listings that name the steel in their title.
  • MagnaMax: 185 listings from 7 makers. Pro-Tech has 117, Guardian Tactical 44, McNees 12, Spyderco 5, RJ Martin 4 and Hogue 2, plus one custom knife. 82 are in stock. The median listed price is $349, and the middle half fall between $310 and $375. The lowest in-stock price in US dollars is $285.00. An eighth maker, Maserin, prices its 634 Frontier MagnaMax in euros (€249), so it is not in these figures.
  • New listings. 62 MagnaMax listings and 17 Cru-Wear listings were first seen in the last 90 days. The 90-day counts leave out Blade HQ, whose listings all carry the same load date in the catalogue. The new Cru-Wear listings include the Zero Tolerance 0316 and 0512DL and Spyderco's Bodacious.

Two things stand out. First, 161 of the 185 MagnaMax listings are Pro-Tech and Guardian Tactical knives, which are automatics. Automatic knives are restricted in some places, so check local law. Cru-Wear comes mostly in manual folders and fixed blades. Second, Benchmade's Adamas family, which has 44 Cru-Wear listings, now also has 31 MagnaCut listings, and the standard Adamas is listed at $325.00 in either steel. 22 of the Cru-Wear listings are in stock, and 17 of the MagnaCut ones.

Browse MagnaMax knives or browse Cru-Wear knives.

Same Spyderco Manix 2 in MagnaMax and Cru-Wear

Spyderco has made the Manix 2 in both steels. On 17 November 2026 the Cru-Wear version, with a brown canvas Micarta handle, was in stock at four stores at $189.00. The MagnaMax version, with a black G-10 handle, had been listed at $180.00 and was sold out at every store Drop Beacon tracks. The two were priced within $9 of each other, so on this model the difference is whether one can be found, not what it costs.

Who should buy MagnaMax, and who should buy Cru-Wear

Buy MagnaMax if you want the longest edge life of the two, you want a stainless blade, and you are happy with an automatic or with one of the few manual MagnaMax folders. Expect to pay around $310 to $375.

Buy Cru-Wear if you want a tougher blade for harder use, you want a manual folder from Spyderco, Benchmade or Zero Tolerance, and you will dry the blade after use. Expect to pay around $230 to $325.

A buyer who wants Cru-Wear's balance in a stainless steel should look at MagnaCut. See MagnaMax vs MagnaCut and M4 vs Cruwear vs Maxamet.

Is MagnaMax better than Cruwear?

For edge retention and rust resistance, yes. MagnaMax tested about 40% ahead of MagnaCut for edge retention, and Cru-Wear tested about level with MagnaCut. MagnaMax is stainless and Cru-Wear is not. For toughness Cru-Wear is likely ahead, and it costs less: the median listed price in Drop Beacon's catalogue on 17 November 2026 was $280 for Cru-Wear and $349 for MagnaMax.

Is Cru-Wear stainless?

No. Cru-Wear contains 7.5% chromium, under the roughly 10% that marks a probably stainless steel. Knife Steel Nerds says it should offer some stain resistance. It still needs to be dried after use, and some Cru-Wear knives have coated blades.

Is Cruwear the same as CPM Cru-Wear, Z-Wear and NSM Wear?

Cruwear, CruWear and Cru-Wear are spellings of one name. Crucible's original Cru-Wear from 1994 was a conventionally made steel, and CPM Cru-Wear is the powder version, which Knife Steel Nerds found to be much tougher. Carpenter's PD#1 and Zapp's Z-Wear share its composition. NSM Wear is the name Niagara Specialty Metals uses for the Cru-Wear it has kept in production, and at least one listing in Drop Beacon's catalogue already uses that name.

Six knives in MagnaMax and Cru-Wear, with live prices

Live prices from the stores Drop Beacon tracks. Three MagnaMax knives first, then three Cru-Wear knives.

Sources

Last updated: 17 November 2026.

Discussion

Sign in to leave a comment.