

On this page▼
- MagnaMax vs Maxamet at a glance
- What MagnaMax and Maxamet are
- Edge retention: Maxamet is still ahead of MagnaMax
- Toughness: MagnaMax likely chips less than Maxamet
- Rust and upkeep: MagnaMax is stainless, Maxamet is not
- Hardness and sharpening
- What Drop Beacon's catalogue shows for MagnaMax and Maxamet
- The same Spyderco in MagnaMax and Maxamet
- Who should buy MagnaMax, and who should buy Maxamet
- Does MagnaMax hold an edge as long as Maxamet?
- Is MagnaMax stainless?
- Which knives come in MagnaMax and Maxamet?
- Six knives in MagnaMax and Maxamet, with live prices
- Related steel comparisons
- Sources
Drop Beacon may earn a commission when you buy through affiliate links on this page — at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.
Short answer: Choose MagnaMax unless maximum edge life is the whole point. MagnaMax is stainless, comes from eight makers in Drop Beacon's catalogue and holds an edge about as long as S110V or CPM-10V. Maxamet very likely still cuts longer, but it can rust, it is slower to sharpen and every Maxamet knife Drop Beacon tracks is a Spyderco.
No direct test of the two steels with numbers stated in text was found for this article. The verdict rests on separate results for each steel, set out below with their sources.
Two terms used below. HRC is the Rockwell C hardness scale, where a higher number means a harder blade (how hardness affects a knife). CATRA is a machine test that measures how much abrasive card a blade cuts before it goes dull.
MagnaMax vs Maxamet at a glance
| MagnaMax | Maxamet | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Stainless powder steel | High speed tool steel, not stainless |
| Who makes it | Designed by Larrin Thomas, sold by Niagara Specialty Metals | Carpenter Technology |
| Introduced | 2026 | 2000 |
| Carbide volume | About 16% | About 22% |
| Hardness | Tested at 62 HRC; makers list 61 to 64.5 HRC | Tested at 68 HRC; up to 71 HRC possible |
| Edge retention | About 40% more than MagnaCut; level with K390 and S110V | Rated beyond the 10-point scale by Knife Steel Nerds |
| Toughness | Level with K390 at 62 HRC | At 66.7 HRC, level with CPM-15V at 65.3 HRC |
| Rust | No rust spots in a 1% saltwater test | Not stainless (4.75% chromium) |
| Listings tracked | 185 from 7 makers | 39, all Spyderco |
| In stock | 82 | 23 |
| Median listed price | $349 | $270 |
| First seen in the last 90 days | 62 | 0 |
Listing figures are from Drop Beacon's catalogue on 17 November 2026. They cover listings priced in US dollars, so Maserin's MagnaMax folder, priced in euros, is not counted.
What MagnaMax and Maxamet are
MagnaMax is a stainless powder steel designed by Dr. Larrin Thomas, the metallurgist who writes Knife Steel Nerds and who designed MagnaCut. He describes it as MagnaCut's recipe with more carbon, vanadium and niobium. Carbides are the hard particles in a steel that resist wear. MagnaMax has about 16% carbide by volume, roughly double MagnaCut, and they are vanadium and niobium carbides with no chromium carbides. Crucible Industries made the first batch in 2023. Thomas wrote in January 2026 that the first commercial batch had reached a few knife companies and that a wide release was planned for the second quarter of 2026. Niagara Specialty Metals sells it and lists it as patent pending.
Maxamet is Carpenter Technology's Micro-Melt Maxamet, a high speed tool steel made from powder. Carpenter lists 2.15% carbon, 13% tungsten, 10% cobalt, 6% vanadium and 4.75% chromium. Knife Steel Nerds dates its introduction to 2000. It was designed for industrial cutting tools, and Spyderco's Maxamet Mule Team blade is dated August 2016 on its product page.
Edge retention: Maxamet is still ahead of MagnaMax
Edge retention is how long a blade keeps cutting before it needs sharpening. Both steels are near the top for this, and Maxamet is higher.
- MagnaMax. Niagara, citing Thomas's testing, puts it about 40% ahead of MagnaCut at 62 HRC. Thomas's own article says its CATRA result matches K390 and Vanadis 8, sits in the same range as CPM-10V and S110V, and is above M390, S30V and CPM-M4.
- Maxamet. Knife Steel Nerds reports a CATRA result of 222 at 68 HRC, on a scale where the reference steel 440C scores 100. In its rating of knife steels it scores Maxamet and Rex 121 above 10 out of 10 for edge retention because they sit so far beyond the rest.
A rough chain of the published numbers: MagnaCut's datasheet lists 135% of 440C, and 40% more than that is about 190% for MagnaMax, against 222 for Maxamet. That is arithmetic across three data sets with different reference blades, not a test result. It suggests Maxamet leads, by less than it leads MagnaCut.
Hardness explains part of the gap. The Maxamet figure is for a blade at 68 HRC and the MagnaMax comparisons are at 62 HRC. Thomas notes that MagnaMax could gain some edge retention at higher hardness, at some cost in toughness.
Toughness: MagnaMax likely chips less than Maxamet
Toughness is a steel's resistance to chipping and breaking. The two steels have not been tested side by side in any text source opened for this article, so this section is an inference from three separate results.
- Thomas measured MagnaMax at 62 HRC as equal to K390 and Vanadis 8, a small step above CPM-10V, and just above S35VN.
- Knife Steel Nerds found Maxamet at 66.7 HRC about as tough as CPM-15V at 65.3 HRC.
- In Niagara's interview with Thomas, the vanadium steels 3V, 4V, 10V and 15V are used to show that more vanadium brings more wear resistance and less toughness. That places 15V below 10V.
Put together, MagnaMax at the hardness knife makers use is likely tougher than Maxamet at the hardness it is run at. Carpenter's own material says Maxamet's toughness at 69 to 71 HRC is somewhat below that of conventional powder high speed steels.
Rust and upkeep: MagnaMax is stainless, Maxamet is not
MagnaMax showed no rust spots in Thomas's 1% saltwater test. In the same test M390 and S110V showed a few small spots and S90V rusted significantly. Niagara's overview page gives the reason: with no large chromium carbides, more chromium stays available to resist corrosion.
Maxamet has 4.75% chromium. Knife Steel Nerds treats about 10% as the level at which a steel is probably stainless, and describes Maxamet's class as not stainless, though more rust resistant than a low alloy steel such as 1095. A Maxamet blade should be dried after use and kept lightly oiled.
Hardness and sharpening
Maxamet is the harder steel by a wide margin. Carpenter says it can reach 71 HRC, and Knife Steel Nerds says its class is designed for at least 67 HRC. For MagnaMax, two makers publish a figure: Maserin lists 61 to 63 HRC on the 634 Frontier and McNees lists 63.5 to 64.5 HRC on the Little Dixon.
Maxamet is also the harder one to sharpen. Knife Steel Nerds says steels of its class are difficult to grind and finish, which can make sharpening difficult too. No sharpening test of MagnaMax has been published in the sources opened for this article. Niagara says its fine carbide structure helps sharpening compared with older stainless steels such as M390, without giving measurements. Both steels are rich in vanadium carbides, which are harder than common aluminium oxide stones, so diamond or CBN stones suit both.
What Drop Beacon's catalogue shows for MagnaMax and Maxamet
These figures are from Drop Beacon's catalogue on 17 November 2026. A listing is one knife at one store, so the same knife at three stores counts three times.
- MagnaMax: 185 listings from 7 makers. Pro-Tech has 117, Guardian Tactical 44, McNees 12, Spyderco 5, RJ Martin 4 and Hogue 2, plus one custom knife. 82 are in stock. The median listed price is $349, and the middle half of listings fall between $310 and $375. The lowest in-stock price in US dollars is $285. An eighth maker, Maserin, prices its 634 Frontier MagnaMax in euros (€249), so it is not in these figures.
- Maxamet: 39 listings, all Spyderco. Seven models, 23 listings in stock, a median listed price of $270.00, and a lowest in-stock price of $192.68, for a Para 3 at Chicago Knife Works. The Maxamet page's headline price, $214.50, counts only listings that name the steel in their title.
- New listings. 62 MagnaMax listings were first seen in the last 90 days. No Maxamet listing was. The 90-day counts leave out Blade HQ, whose listings all carry the same load date in the catalogue.
One thing the MagnaMax count hides: 161 of the 185 listings are Pro-Tech and Guardian Tactical knives, which are automatics. Automatic knives are restricted in some places, so check local law. The manual production folders in MagnaMax that were in stock on 17 November were the Hogue Saxum button lock, at $349.95 from two stores, and the Maserin 634 Frontier, which Maserin prices in euros (€249). Every Maxamet knife is a manual Spyderco folder, apart from the Mule Team fixed blade.
Browse MagnaMax knives or browse Maxamet knives.
The same Spyderco in MagnaMax and Maxamet
Spyderco has made the Manix 2 in both steels. Stores listed the Manix 2 in MagnaMax with a G-10 handle at $180.00, and the Manix 2 Lightweight in Maxamet at $270.00. Both were sold out at every store Drop Beacon tracks on 17 November 2026, so neither is a knife to plan around today.
Spyderco has also sold both steels as Mule Team blades, its bare fixed blades for testing steels. The MagnaMax Mule Team was listed at $75.00 and is sold out. The Maxamet one was listed at $109.95 and Spyderco's page says it is no longer in production.
Who should buy MagnaMax, and who should buy Maxamet
Buy MagnaMax if you want long edge life in a blade that does not need rust care, you want a choice of makers, or you want an automatic. Expect to pay around $310 to $375.
Buy Maxamet if you want the longer-lasting edge of the two, you will dry and oil the blade, you own diamond stones, and you want a Spyderco. It costs less than MagnaMax: four of the seven models have in-stock listings under $300.
If neither fits, MagnaCut is the easier steel to own and to find. See MagnaMax vs MagnaCut and Maxamet vs MagnaCut.
Does MagnaMax hold an edge as long as Maxamet?
Probably not. Knife Steel Nerds rates Maxamet beyond its normal 10-point edge retention scale, and places MagnaMax level with K390, CPM-10V and S110V, which are inside that scale. The published Maxamet result is for a blade at 68 HRC, about six points harder than the MagnaMax results. No direct test of the two with numbers stated in text was found for this article.
Is MagnaMax stainless?
Yes. MagnaMax showed no rust spots in Larrin Thomas's 1% saltwater test, a test in which M390 and S110V showed a few small spots. Maxamet is not stainless: it contains 4.75% chromium and needs to be kept dry and oiled.
Which knives come in MagnaMax and Maxamet?
In Drop Beacon's catalogue on 17 November 2026, MagnaMax knives come from Pro-Tech (Scapegoat Compact, Synapse 2 and TR-4 automatics), Guardian Tactical (APEX automatics), McNees (Little Dixon), Hogue (Saxum), Maserin (634 Frontier), Spyderco (Manix 2 and Mule Team, both sold out) and RJ Martin (Q36-R). Maxamet knives are all Spyderco: Manix 2 Lightweight, Para 3, Para Military 2, Native 5 Lightweight, Sage 1, Sage 5 Lightweight and the Mule Team blade.
Six knives in MagnaMax and Maxamet, with live prices
Live prices from the stores Drop Beacon tracks. Three MagnaMax knives first, then three Maxamet knives.

Blade HQ
Hogue Saxum Button Lock Knife Black Aluminum/Carbon Fiber (2.8" SW MagnaMax)From $349.95 at Blade HQ

Blade HQ
Spyderco Native 5 Lightweight Lockback Knife Gray FRN (3" Satin Maxamet) C41PGY5From $236.25 at Blade HQ

Blade HQ
Spyderco Sage 5 Lightweight Compression Lock Knife Gray FRN (3" Satin Maxamet)From $258.75 at Blade HQ

Blade HQ
Spyderco Paramilitary 2 Knife Dark Gray G-10 (3.4" Stonewash Maxamet) C81GPDGY2From $298.50 at Blade HQ
Related steel comparisons
- MagnaMax vs MagnaCut: full data and a verdict
- Maxamet vs MagnaCut
- MagnaMax vs Cruwear
- S110V vs MagnaCut, with MagnaMax vs S110V
- M4 vs Cruwear vs Maxamet
Sources
- Knife Steel Nerds (Larrin Thomas): MagnaMax, super hard high speed steels, edge retention testing of seven more steels and knife steel ratings
- Niagara Specialty Metals: MagnaMax overview, MagnaMax data sheet, interview on MagnaMax performance and CPM MagnaCut data sheet
- Carpenter Technology: Micro-Melt Maxamet alloy page and article on the alloy
- Maker product pages: Maserin 634 Frontier MagnaMax, McNees Little Dixon MagnaMax and Spyderco's Maxamet and MagnaMax models
- Drop Beacon's catalogue of tracked listings, 17 November 2026
Last updated: 17 November 2026.
🔥 Trending This Week
- 1

Spyderco Charisma Folding Knife Red FRN Handle CTS-BD1N Plain Edge Satin Finish C259PRD
White Mountain Knives
$97.50
- 2

Control Series
GeeOne
$249.90
- 3

Benchmade Mini Adira 18065S Folding Knife – 3.21" Stonewash CPM-MagnaCut Drop Point Partially Serrated Blade, Depth Blue Grivory Handle, AXIS Lock
Blade City
$225.00
- 4

Pro-Tech Duke 2 Automatic Knife Nautical Aluminum Handle Stonewash 2.65" 20CV Drop Point DUKE2101-20CV-NAUTICAL
White Mountain Knives
$250.00
- 5

QSP Penguin Folding Knife Christmas Glow-in-the-Dark Resin Handle 14C28N Sheepsfoot Plain Edge Christmas Edition QS130GL-H1 MX
White Mountain Knives
$89.00
Sign in to leave a comment.
You might also like

MagnaMax vs Cruwear: Which Knife Steel to Buy, and for Whom
MagnaMax holds an edge longer and is stainless. Cru-Wear is likely tougher, costs less and comes in far more manual folders. Test data, prices and stock.

S110V vs MagnaCut (and MagnaMax): Which Steel to Buy
MagnaCut is the better buy for most people. S110V holds an edge longer but chips more easily, and MagnaMax matches S110V's edge life with more toughness. Test data, prices and stock.

Maxamet vs MagnaCut: Which Knife Steel to Buy, and for Whom
MagnaCut is the better buy for most people. Maxamet holds an edge longer, but it can rust, it is slow to sharpen and every tracked Maxamet knife is a Spyderco. Test data, prices and stock.

Nitro-X7 vs MagnaCut: Which Is Better? What's Published
Which is better? Nobody can say yet from published figures. MagnaCut's test numbers are public and none were found for Nitro-X7 on 17 November 2026. What each steel is, who uses it and what is in stock.

